“Love, Energy, and Heavy Music, baby!”
Those words, if uttered by just about any other rock group, would be completely mundane. But to hear a group like Metallica say something like that… is this a concert or a yoga routine? Love, energy, heavy music. It’s almost like Love Angel Music Baby, but somehow, dumber. Baffling.
I’ve been baffled a lot by some musicians lately.
Ed Sheeran, for instance, is an insanely baffling figure… hugely popular, with some of the most tortuous unlistenable music known to man. Ed Sheeran, with his immense (and frankly unwarranted) fanbase of former tumblrinas and wannabe hipsters, has chosen to eschew sanity by taking a “middle of the road” stance on politics. Interesting, as he’s only decided to be outspokenly milquetoast on Palestine, but he has no problem taking sides on other global issues. In fact, Ed Sheeran is completely fine advertising the fact that he is on Ukraine’s side of the Russia/Ukraine fiasco, but somehow even showing a teeny tiny bit of empathy for survivors of an ongoing genocide is “too political”. He couldn’t keep touring with someone who said two HORRIBLY offensive words (Free Palestine) because it was ruining the chill and wholesome vibe. Come on guys, let’s all hold hands and kumbayah, that’ll solve things, right? Baffling.
Another baffling musician: Taylor Swift. I’ll be the first to admit that I was never a Swiftie, and frankly her music is so saccharine Disney Princess that I have a hard time believing her fans are sincere. Another outspokenly milquetoast musician that picks and chooses certain political stances when it directly benefits her image. But the thing that racks my brain the most lately is not even actually political, it’s just bizarre.
We all know that The Life of a Showgirl was Taylor’s biggest flop. I’m trying to be objective and as nice and polite as I can possibly be about it, but even Swifties will admit that TLOAS is mid at best. We all know, as well, that Taylor is addicted to easy money-grab opportunities from her fans, so it’s not shocking that she’d release 30 billion variants and remixes and “Taylor’s Version”s of even her worst album. I was taken a bit aback that she somehow had MORE songs to add to an already abysmal medley, but not surprised.
But… why on God’s green earth is there a song about CLEVELAND, of all places, on the bonus addition to TLOAS? What??
Okay, I understand that Travis Kelce’s family is from Cleveland and it’s supposed to be a wink and a nod to that, but why not just write directly about how nice they are?? Of course, obviously, the song isn’t even about Cleveland or her in-laws… somehow. It’s about her haters being super jealous of how sexy Travis Kelce is. Again, incredibly fucking baffling choices being made in the music industry. Who is telling her these ideas are good? They just aren’t. People who are secure in their relationships don’t have to constantly remind everyone around them how sexy and hot their husbands are. They don’t care about haters. It’s an incredibly childish and silly thing to care about in the grand scheme of things. Baffling.
This brings me back to Metallica and their childish (and spineless) concert devotion to being deliberately apolitical. I am not a huge Metallica listener to be quite honest, they are just too angry and intimidating for me to fully devote myself to listening to all the time. I do enjoy a couple of their songs. But it was my understanding before now that they wrote about the horrors of war and the police state. Metal, in general, tends to lean into anti-establishment themes. A band named “Metallica” that genuinely is the most popular metal band on earth, should theoretically have some political views that ruffle a few feathers. Left or right.
So color me shocked and astounded when I saw the viral clip of James Hetfield pausing mid-show to announce that Metallica is the band of “love, energy, and heavy music”. What? Which Metallica songs are about love and vibes and bliss and all that? Does Metallica even listen to Metallica? I’ve never once heard a Metallica song and gotten warm fuzzy happy feelings. You listen to Metallica when you wanna set a dumpster on fire, or punch a hole in a wall. They’re not Phish.
We all know that James Hetfield was referencing both Ed Sheeran’s apolitical posturing AND Hayley Williams consistently calling out ICE and racism at her shows. To me, a metal band that is so deeply established that they have a fucking residency at the Las Vegas Sphere has no place punching downward (if you can even call it down, tbh) at someone because they’re “too political”. James, you represent a genre of anger and defiance. What is so scary or freaky about Hayley Williams telling ICE to suck her dick? Is too metal for you? Baffling.

